I read over on Comics Worth Reading that Newsarama is planning on doing a major reboot later this month. The popular comic book website was acquired last year by digital media company Imaginova. Evidently they will be meshing more with the other websites owned by Imaginova.
From Newsarama administrator Matt Brady:
We’ll save discussion and previews about what the main page will look like for a little bit (it looks really, really good), and focus on what is happening with the message board system. We’ll be moving on from vBulletin. It served its purpose admirably for many years, but as Newsarama has grown so have our technical needs and vBulletin just doesn’t support the full experience we want to give you. In the coming weeks we will be moving over to a Pluck-based message board system. It’s the system used by our sister sites LiveScience, Space.com and Aviation.com. Now, I see those wheels spinning. Don’t worry, all your brilliant posts aren’t disappearing into some bottomless abyss. We’ll be archiving the current boards as read-only. You’ll be able to view them at: LOCKED forums at forums.newsarama.com. To be totally clear the existing topics and posts will not be moving to the new boards.
Something not mentioned in Matt Brady’s post is that if your particular user ID is already being used over on LiveScience, Space.com or Aviation.com, you’re out of luck.
I went over to Space.com and created an account to use on the Space.com message board. I then went over to Aviation.com and tried to do the same thing using the same user ID. No dice. It said that user ID was already taken. What this means is that someone, anyone, can go over to any one of these “sister sites” and create a user ID using an already existing Newsarama user ID and there is nothing the person over on Newsarama that originally had the user ID can do about it.
Another problem people will have is that over on the other Pluck-based message board system, user ID’s using two words is not possible. That means instead of using for instance “John Smith”, a person will be forced to use “John_Smith”.
Both of these wrinkles will make it difficult to find and read past messages posted on the original archived Newsarama website.
I posted a question about this problem over in the thread announcing the switch. This is the response from Newsarama administrator doublehelix:
Please note that we have a contingency plan for this. I don’t mean to be secretive about it, because this is NOT my intention. I just can’t discuss the details.
Please know that we have thought about this and have planned a solution. If, for some reason, the particular solution is problematic in your eyes, I am here to work it out. That’s part of my job as the Community Manager.
So they have a plan in place on how to deal with this problem. They just can’t talk about it. It’s a secret.
This reminds me of Nixon’s “secret plan” to get out of Vietnam bragged about during the 1968 Presidential election. There was a plan. He just couldn’t tell people what it was. It was a secret.
I think this is a mistake on the part of Imaginova. A website such as Newsarama is only as good as it’s foundation. One of the strengths of the site is that it has a forum that contains posts going back years. Forcing members to start over on a different site that is tied to other websites dedicated to other interests seems like a really bad idea. If people have to start over, they very well may jump on over to another website that is focused solely on comic books.
Maybe everyone will.
Tags: Comic Books, Imaginova, Newsarama